|
Welders, plumbers, and many other building and fabrication trades
frequently use oxy-fuel cutting, a process that uses a fuel
gas
and oxygen to cut metals. A torch with a specially designed
tip is
connected to a fuel tank, typically acetylene or one of three popular
fuel alternatives, and mixes the fuel with oxygen in order to produce a
high-temperature flame cone to cut through metals.
Oxy-cutting
with fuels such as acetylene provide simple ways to cut metals rapidly
without the wear and tear of a saw. This cutting application is very
portable and requires a minimal upfront investment that is especially
appealing to the occasional user who doesn't want to invest in an
expensive plasma cutting unit.
The following resource article will introduce the basic fuels, cutting
tips, usage, and safety precautions for oxy-cutting.
Types of Cutting Fuels
There are four main kinds of gas used for oxy-cutting: acetylene,
propane, propylene, and MAPP (methyl acetylene propadiene).
Acetylene: Acetylene
has been the cutting fuel of choice for oxy-welding, brazing, and
cutting because it reaches the highest possible temperature, provides
clean, efficient cuts, and offers versatility. The heat in acetylene's
flame is concentrated on the inside of the flame's cone.
The
high cost of acetylene and its recent
shortage have led many welders to
consider alternative fuels that don't necessarily burn quite as hot as
acetylene (though the HGX propane additive may change that) but offer
their own advantages.
Propane for Oxy-cutting Propane and other
propane-based fuels are frequently used as substitutes for acetylene.
In fact, many cutting operations have switched over to propane in order
to save on fuel costs. Propane's outer
cone offers a high number of BTUs, as opposed to the
flame for acetylene which concentrates the heat inside the cone. Welders
used to acetylene will need to adapt their techniques by preheating and
cutting with the outer cone of a propane flame in order to achieve the
appropriate cutting temperature.
Welders who use propane instead of acetylene may need to wait a little
longer in order to heat the metal, but if they use the outer edge of
the heat cone, they’ll find that preheating won’t take much longer than
acetylene. Switching from acetylene to propane or any other alternative
fuel will require equipment changes for the torch tip, torch itself,
and hose depending on the fuel.
HGX Propane: HGX-3 is a new product on the
market that
can be added to propane in order to increase its performance. This
mixture, referred to commonly as HGX propane, cuts metal at
temperatures comparable to acetylene. One gallon of HGX-3 can be added
to 1,000 gallons of propane.
HGX-3 increases the flame temperature of propane gas by 15%, reaching
flame temperatures of 5400°F and uses less oxygen than
acetylene. This makes HGX propane a viable alternative for welders used
to the heat output and speed achieved with acetylene for flame cutting.
Much like other alternative fuels, HGX propane
reduces slag and makes for a smoother, cleaner cut.
One of the biggest advantages alternative fuel gases such as HGX
propane have over acetylene is its supply and storage. Acetylene must
be supplied in individual cylinders with a maximum capacity of
approximately 400 cubic feet per cylinder, while the alternative fuel
gases can be supplied in either cylinders, bulk stations, and even from
a pipeline.
Propylene: Much like propane, propylene is
often
misunderstood as ineffective as a fuel for cutting since it requires an
injector torch in order to achieve optimal heat flow and cuts and
concentrates the heat on the outer edges of the heat cone. The tips for
propylene rarely need cleaning and provide eight holes for effective
pre-heating. In other words, effectively using propylene rests entirely
on having the correct torch and tip setup.
Welding Tips and Tricks recommends propylene
as a great alternative
since it offers no 15 psi limit on working pressures, no soot, more
BTU's of heat for heating thick metal, and quick cuts
on
metal.
MAPP: MAPP gas is commonly used instead of
acetylene
because it can be used above 15 psi and is therefore far less dangerous
while cutting steel up to 12 inches thick. MAPP burns at a lower
temperature than acetylene and is a liquefied petroleum gas that can be
stored more easily since it compresses easily.
MAPP gas is
more commonly used as a substitute for acetylene in Oxy-welding. While
other gases such as propane, propylene, and HGX Propane are more widely
used for cutting and brazing, MAPP can be used in place of acetylene,
even though MAPP doesn’t burn quite as hot and can be expensive for
large-scale operations.
Tips on Cutting Torches
The tips on torches are designed for each specific kind of
fuel and
will determine how effectively you can cut. Using the wrong tip for a
particular kind of fuel will prevent you from reaching the optimal
temperature and will limit the torch's effectiveness for cutting. For
example, an acetylene torch tip does not have the correct number of
holes for cutting with propane, and therefore propane with an acetylene
tip won't reach optimal heat and will be extremely ineffective for
cutting.
Torch cutting tips come in
two styles: one piece and two-piece.
One-piece tips are made from copper alloy and are used with acetylene.
They are machined with either 4 or 6 preheated
holes and can handle light, medium, and heavy preheats. There are
different 1-piece torch cutting tips that perform different functions
from gouging out metal to cutting sheet metal and other specialty
functions. One-piece tips use methyl acetylene propadiene (MAPP),
acetylene, and propylene, though each fuel has a different number of
holes that match a particular kind of fuel, so be sure to take note of
the number of holes in each torch tip.
Two-piece tips require cooler and slower
burning fuel gases such as propane. In the case of propane, it's also
critical to use the right kind of torch. An injector torch allows
welders to make cuts that some claim
to be cleaner and faster than acetylene. Propane also offers more
versatility for bending and heating.
Finding the right tip for a job can be confusing. The American Welding
Society (AWS) issued a Uniform
Designation System for Oxy-Fuel Nozzles back in 2000. In
it they asked
that all standard tips have the manufacturer's name stamped on them as
well as the identifying fuel symbol, maximum material thickness, and
part number for data and reference; however many manufacturers still do
not follow these designations due to the extra manufacturing costs
entailed. When shopping for tips, check the oxygen bore
size, orifice size, and fuel gas required.
Torch Cutting Basics
When oxy-cutting, managing the oxygen
flow rate will determine what kind of cut is made. Torch cutting with
too much oxygen both adds to the overall cost and results in a wide cut
with curved edges, rather than the sharp, clean edges that are desired
when cutting with a torch. Too little oxygen produces a slow, uneven
cut that will be frustrating. The flow rate of the oxygen should match
the manufacturer's specifications for the torch tip used for cutting.
Cutting with a torch is performed by preheating the metal and then
cutting at a high temperature. This process will melt the metal being
cut. Therefore set up a grate or other object that can catch the melted
metal.
Oxy-cutting
is primarily used for cutting steel. It is almost always twice as fast
as a grinder and can cut large sections with very little effort or
noise. Ferrous metals up to two inches thick can be effectively cut
with oxy-cutting fuels such as acetylene.
Torch Cutting Safety
Oxy-cutting fuels are among the most flammable and require proper
safety precautions for storage and usage. Acetylene is hazardous above
15 psi pressure, as it becomes unstable and
explosively decomposes.
One
should never use concrete as base for cutting since concrete holds
water. When the cutting torches heat makes contact with the concrete,
the heat will cause
the water in the concrete to expand and the concrete to explode.
Take extra caution and
time when cleaning the tips of cutting torches. Make sure the orifice
is always free of any debris and smooth. Use protective welding gear at
all times and welding screens. Make sure you are using the right size
tip for the job and that the tip matches the fuel use.
Hoses
should regularly be checked for fuel leaks. In addition, using the
wrong kind of hose for a particular fuel will deteriorate your hose
over time. While some welders have found they can occasionally use a
fuel such as propane with an acetylene hose, the best long term
solution is to use the proper hose with each type of fuel.
If
your hose leaks, fuel gases that are denser than air (Propane,
Propylene, MAPP, Butane,
etc...) will most likely collect in lower areas and present a flame
hazard, especially in basements, sinks, storm drains, and other
enclosed areas. Cutting fuels are made to burn, so take proper
precautions with your work clothing, location of fire extinguishers,
ventilation, and equipment maintenance.
Learn More About Torch Cutting
Written exclusively for BakersGas.com by Ed Cyzewski
|